Elizabeth Barrette (ysabetwordsmith) wrote,
Elizabeth Barrette
ysabetwordsmith

  • Mood:

Supporting Artists

Here's an article about music and crowdfunding.  There's a very difficult balance between creativity and survival.  Too much idealism and you starve.  Too much commercialism and you produce dreck.  So too are there two poles of audience interaction: too low a price tag and the artist can't afford to keep working, too high a price tag and the audience either can't afford to buy or won't because they feel it's a ripoff.

Culture is an exchange.  In order to continue, a society must meet the survival and social needs of its citizens.  They need ways of supporting themselves, interacting, and expressing ideas.  What people value tends to continue.  What they do not value will be hidden or lost.  So if you don't support art, then you wind up with very little art, of poorer quality.  If you don't make sure people have enough to live on, then not only do they suffer, but they can't afford to buy stuff and your economy tanks.  Not everything has to be a cash exchange, that's a relatively recent phenomenon historically speaking.  But there must be an exchange of value and people must get their needs met.

This is a time of great challenge and great potential.  A lot of people are getting into creative work because that's all they CAN do -- they aren't permitted a day job by the people who control the businesses.  They still need to survive, so they scrabble for what they can do that DOESN'T require someone else's permission to have a job.  That's often art, music, writing, things that are less controlled than businesses you need an expensive license even to attempt.   There are business models now that help connect creators directly to the audience in ways that cut out middlemen and route more money to the people making stuff.  But the audience can be a stingy bastard sometimes.  That's especially true if people don't have enough to live on, or if they've had their pockets picked so much they FEEL like that don't have enough even after they've managed to scrape up more.  The pervasive sense of threat, that failure and starvation are just a day's bad luck and a few weeks of unemployment away, erodes the cohesion of society as a whole.

What can you do?  Think mindfully about what it costs you to make things and how much your talent is worth.  Think mindfully about how much other people's work is worth to you, and whether you can afford that.  If money is tight, which it often is when a few people are hogging so damn much of it, then look for alternatives.  You might not have cash to pay for what you want, but you may have something the other person wants that you could trade.  Money is only valuable when there's enough to get the job done.  If there isn't, it's useless as a medium of exchange.  But you always have your skills.  You have resources.  Other people have different ones.  So trade.

And value each other's hard work, because somebody has to, and it's painfully clear that the people at the top of the heap care fuckall about you, art, or the sustainability of society.

Tags: art, cyberfunded creativity, economics, music, networking, writing
Subscribe

  • A Little Slice of Terramagne: YardMap

    Sadly the main program is dormant, but the YardMap concept is awesome, and many of its informative articles remain. YardMap was a citizen science…

  • Winterfest in July Bingo Card 7-1-21

    Here is my card for the Winterfest in July Bingo fest. It runs from July 1-30. Celebrate all the holidays and traditions of winter! ( See all my…

  • Bingo

    I have made bingo down the B, G, and O columns of my 6-1-21 card for the Cottoncandy Bingo fest. I also have one extra fill. B1 (caretaking) --…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 15 comments
*Applauds*

Well said, and it needs to be said.

And also heard and listened to, which are harder.
Capitalism distorts the value of things. In Ancient Egypt, they had the right idea about art: it was one of the most valuable things in their world, sacred even. (There wasn't much creativity, but oh well.) But capitalism puts most people in survival mode, which distorts the value of things. Let's look at the things that are underpaid and under-appreciated in our society:
* Teachers
* Artists (there are exceptions, but on the whole, it's true)
* People who work with the developmentally disabled

These, and possibly others, should be of the HIGHEST value, and should be getting paid the MOST to do their jobs, especially teachers. But no, corporate America wants people smart enough to run the machines but too dumb to question authority, and well-funded schools tend to produce kids that are too smart for our plutocrats to abide.

And then, too, some groups find ways to inflate the value of their work to absurd heights. A good example of this is the medical profession: important, yes, but the price of everything in the medical profession is so absurdly overpriced that doctors make money hand over fist. (If you don't think medical prices are absurdly overpriced, my roommate once got charged $300 just for a single ride in an ambulance. That's at least 1000% higher than it ought to be, and I only wish that were an exaggeration. An ambulance ride should be $30; 1000% of 30 is 300. And then you get professions like chiropractors, which back in the 90's were charging $30 for 10 minutes of pushing on your back. And therapists, charging as much as $100 an hour for you to vent your feelings at them. WTF??? Prices like that, they almost need a space between the e and the r.)

Another good example of a group artificially inflating their worth is colleges. College tuition is absurdly high, and literally the only reason for it is greed; the people running the colleges keep raising the tuition to see how many gullible people they can get to pay those ridiculous prices, putting themselves into lifelong debt they cannot legally claim bankruptcy on. Add to it the absurdly high cost for books, the fact that used books are not allowed in most colleges, and the fact that going to college is a gamble anyway, and it's a Ponzii scheme to make Enron look like chump change.

I would count sports figures in that group, too, but honestly *their* value is being inflated by the people making money selling tickets to the games, the owners of the teams. But the basic value distortion is the same: here we have a group of people who shouldn't even be able to make a career out of tossing a ball around, or at the very least should be making just enough at it to get by, but instead they're making millions of dollars every year. Honestly, the salaries for sports figures and teachers should be switched around. But capitalism encourages people to care about nothing but greed. It is an inherently evil economic system but the evil just keeps perpetuating itself because greed is a powerful motivator, and money is power.
>> Capitalism distorts the value of things. <<

I agree.

>> Another good example of a group artificially inflating their worth is colleges. <<

This can be protested by hiring people based on their skill, not on paperwork.
Many doctors are not raking in the money. My stepson is a doctor, and while he's making decent money, he worries mightily about how to pay off the loans he had to take out to get the training; fortunately, his wife is well-off.

It's the institutions- insurance companies, big pharm, instrument makers, hospitals, etc.- that are raking in the big bucks. Something single-payer would put a lid on...
I wrote a whole series of articles - the most recent this past summer - called Music in the Post-Scarcity Environment. It's a bit more on the mechanics around all of this, but there are a few essays right up front on how we got here, which is to say, commentary on devaluing the entire concept of owning (copies of) music.
That is epic. I am thrilled to see someone else writing on these topics. I have linked your series in my Crowdfunding resources.

If you haven't already found crowdfunding then I recommend that as a venue for connecting creative people and patrons. We are keenly interested in discussing where cyberfunded creativity is now and where it's going. So if you're still posting about stuff like this, by all means post or link to it there.
Thanks! I post all kinds of stuff. I haven't added anything to that series since last summer, but if I come up with something else to write about, I totally will.

I have a few series running, really. A few have mostly wound down, as I've finished long-term projects, like the studio buildout series and the travelling instrument case buildout series, but things like the above and the sexism and racism in geek culture posts get added to whenever I think of something. XD

Basically I tried to write fiction and was terrible at it? But I'm not a terrible essayist and technical writer. So I still write words, just... not fiction. Except in songs, I guess. :D
I write pretty much everything, including nonfiction. I've sold lots of articles, but not in crowdfunding. There are a few folks crowdfunding nonfiction, though, and I would love to see more of that.
Agreed (with the linked post). Plussed. "And value each other's hard work, because somebody has to," as well...except that I need the money I finally accumulated and cashed out from Paypal to pay an annual bill. Sigh.
I'm glad you liked this.

There are noncash support methods for crowdfunding also! It's about exchanging value not necessarily money. Your attention, word-of-mouth advertising, links, recommendations, feedback, prompts, etc. all have different benefits. Use what you have.

I'm usually broke too. If I had enough money to live on comfortably, then I would set a monthly budget as a percentage of my crowdfunding take to reinvest in other people's crowdfunded projects. As it is, I make a $5-10 donation when I can afford it. BUT I am one heck of a barker, and a lot of people read me for the purpose of finding new projects. That matters. I'm also a dandy source of ideas.
You are indeed a good barker. (I "plus" things on Google madly but haven't done much with Tsu, and only on Monday night even opened an account on Twitter.)
It is interesting that while money was introduced as an improvement over barter, now barter has become an improvement over money, at least some of the time.
If people have enough money to exchange, it outcompetes barter by providing a convenient abstract trading medium. If people do not have enough money, it is useless for that, or worse than useless when its lack prevents them from meeting their needs in other ways because they've forgotten the alternatives. You always have your skills. When the official economy fails to meet people's needs, a shadow economy will arise to do that, because needs don't go away.
Since we are living in a kleptocracy, where the the benefits of our productivity are stolen from us and given to the already-rich...

Well, barter takes us out of that.

Money worked really well to ease the problems of barter, like- what if I want apples, and can offer yarn, but the apple vendor doesn't want yarn but wants a knife. It gets unwieldy pretty fast! However, the PLUS is that no one gets to siphon off part of the value in each transaction.

Hmm. I may have an essay here...
>> Since we are living in a kleptocracy, where the the benefits of our productivity are stolen from us and given to the already-rich... <<

That's a problem.

>> Well, barter takes us out of that. <<

It helps, at least.

>> Money worked really well to ease the problems of barter, like- what if I want apples, and can offer yarn, but the apple vendor doesn't want yarn but wants a knife. It gets unwieldy pretty fast! However, the PLUS is that no one gets to siphon off part of the value in each transaction. <<

True. There are barter exchanges, but they are taxed in cash.

>> Hmm. I may have an essay here... <<

Good idea.

  • A Little Slice of Terramagne: YardMap

    Sadly the main program is dormant, but the YardMap concept is awesome, and many of its informative articles remain. YardMap was a citizen science…

  • Winterfest in July Bingo Card 7-1-21

    Here is my card for the Winterfest in July Bingo fest. It runs from July 1-30. Celebrate all the holidays and traditions of winter! ( See all my…

  • Bingo

    I have made bingo down the B, G, and O columns of my 6-1-21 card for the Cottoncandy Bingo fest. I also have one extra fill. B1 (caretaking) --…