Elizabeth Barrette (ysabetwordsmith) wrote,
Elizabeth Barrette
ysabetwordsmith

  • Mood:

Flawed Science

 [personal profile] dialecticdreamer has a thoughtful post about flawed science and how that rarely appears in science fiction.  So many stories that haven't been done to death yet!
Tags: networking, reading, science, science fiction, writing
Subscribe

  • Goldenrod Gall Contents

    Apparently all kinds of things go on inside goldenrod galls, beyond the caterpillars who make them. Fascinating. I've seen the galls but haven't…

  • Science and Spirituality

    Here's an article about science and spirituality, sort of. It doesn't have a very wide view of either. Can you be scientific and spiritual? This…

  • Geniuses

    This article asks if geniuses are real. Gee thanks, assholes. It's not enough to be treated like a vending machine, now you want to play the erasure…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 9 comments
"Yet, when science (which is often vaguely defined or mis-categorized, especially) is shown as wrong, it is inevitably the bad /application/ of science by zealots or Luddites, rather than the science itself which is flawed."
I'm floored to think that I've never thought of this myself!
This is an excellent article and I'm glad you shared it with us.
Thanks!
:)
Yeah, suddenly I'm wanting to write about scientific mistakes and dead ends. This very neatly dovetails with Tuesday's "mad science" theme so I am hopeful of relevant prompts.
Something else has occurred to me: It takes someone who really understands the science thoroughly to figure out exactly where the science is flawed.
I wonder what would happen if you have a new science which get written up by people who really don't know it as well as they think they do!
Instructions are EVERYTHING....right? So what happens if the instructions aren't correct?
Perhaps this could be one of your prompts...
:)

That happened to the Wright Brothers. While they were working on their airplane models, they realized that one of the reference books was wrong, and the wrong numbers in there were making things not work in the models. So they cobbled up a wind tunnel and used models to redo the calculations. I think it was the equations for wing shape and lift. There was a documentary that mentioned it, very cool stuff.

This is the kind of thing that happens a lot in The Blueshift Troupers where people are dealing not only with alien biotech but also the changes to Earth-origin lifeforms that sometimes happen in transit. When people are trying to figure stuff out, sometimes they get it wrong, and other folks build on that and it causes problems.
You also need to write something about when an alien science/tech gets twisted into something really wonderful.
:)
I'm cool with that too. But it immediately makes me think of the joke about the computer user who used the disc tray as a cup holder -- because that was what she needed it to be. I strongly suspect that kind of divide would happen in working with alien technology: you could get it to do something and maybe even something useful, but not necessarily what it was meant to do or did best.
I keep wondering when people will begin upcycling their old computers into useful objects rather than simply dump them at the Goodwill.
:}

One of my favorite characters in Sharon Lee and Steve Miller is Aelliana Caylon. She is a mathematician who determines that the calculations for space jump are wrong. Scouts and pilots love her.

There are 2 free ebooks in the series, though neither has her in it. It is worthwhile to Google Liaden Universe for suggested reading order. It is an excellent character focused sci fi series.
Agreed! I'm currently reading Necessity's Child. All honor to the Caylon.