* Non-forceful verbal resistance (crying, pleading, etc.) is 4% effective in halting the attempted rape.
* Forceful verbal resistance (screaming, etc.) is 50-56% effective.
* Running away is 85% effective.
* Physical violence is 86% effective. Striking works better than shoving or wrestling.
* Armed resistance (knives, guns, etc.) is 99% effective, and furthermore reduces the rate of injury to the attempted rape victim below statistical significance.
* One third of the women who were sexually attacked did successfully avoid sexual contact by resisting.
This matches the resources I saw in my women's studies classes. It directly clashes with most advice on what to do if sexually assaulted. Of course, women who injure men are far more likely to be prosecuted and harshly punished, whereas men are frequently allowed to harm women. But in general, if someone attacks you and you are willing to hurt them, the odds of success are strongly in your favor.
June 21 2014, 11:56:23 UTC 7 years ago
I suspect your numbers don't reflect this because rape during DV isn't counted separately, it's usually just classed as domestic violence.
As an aside, apparently military-grade pepper spray is the most effective non-lethal deterrent, or to put it another way, most effective deterrent short of killing the perpetrator. Probably because it's hard to do anything after a dose of that. [you can't see, breath or think of anything other than the burning pain.]
It surprises me not, that it's also banned from public ownership.
Well...
June 22 2014, 06:49:46 UTC 7 years ago
June 21 2014, 17:46:44 UTC 7 years ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDipspMAyJg
She has been taught the right moves: how to punch with karate force, the kick to the testicles, boxing the ears. Also to get our and away as soon as possible in case she broke some law defending herself.
The point is that these moves are all easy to learn if one is not "disabled / challenged" in some way -- *all* young women should be taught them and taught to use them.
As you point out, this pathetic boy in the subway was NOT expecting any real resistance. Once punched, he immediately spread his legs a little to prepare to hit her back, and left himself open to the groin kick.
One reason I liked seeing this is that the incident had no bad long term effects. The attacker probably got up and walked home about ten minutes later, and I hope he never tried casual robbery again. (Though the groin kick might have prevented future sexual violence as well.)
Thoughts
June 21 2014, 20:15:04 UTC 7 years ago
Awesome.
>> The point is that these moves are all easy to learn if one is not "disabled / challenged" in some way -- *all* young women should be taught them and taught to use them. <<
I think everyone should have opportunities to learn self-defense, although it shouldn't be forced. Disabled people may also defend themselves, but often need specialized training and tactics.
June 21 2014, 18:33:28 UTC 7 years ago
But I think the hard part is that most rapes aren't the kind where people are easily able to make the shift to "I should be willing to draw a gun to protect myself," and I'm really not sure the law is ready for that, either - except, obviously, when the assailant is a violent stranger.
Well...
June 21 2014, 18:48:03 UTC 7 years ago
Common advice is not to fight back because it will raise the chance of injury. But that raises the chance of rape, which is also injury. The most recommended strategies are the least effective ones. That's starting to change, but very slowly.
>> But I think the hard part is that most rapes aren't the kind where people are easily able to make the shift to "I should be willing to draw a gun to protect myself," <<
Yes, that's true.
While you are certainly entitled to protect yourself at any point after you say "no" and the attacker does not stop, one excellent threshold for justifying armed resistance is after the perpetrator has broken the law i.e. committed sexual assault by grabbing your intimate parts or assault by trying to hit you, that sort of thing. It helps to know the laws for your area so that you understand what forms of contact are explicitly illegal.
June 21 2014, 20:58:46 UTC 7 years ago
These might be useful in the stranger danger rapes... but those are like 10% of rapes. In the situations that afflicted my family, I imagine it would've been dangerous. What I REALLY would love to see as rape resistance strategies is how to recognize emotional abuse and manipulation that usually presage rapes, and also more community backlash against perpetrators so people like my mother wouldn't be left without recourse.
--Rogan
Well...
June 21 2014, 21:29:57 UTC 7 years ago
Defensive strategies for rape are primarily aimed at assault by strangers, and secondarily at acquaintance rape where a social encounter turns threatening. As you say, they are far less useful in cases of incest or domestic abuse. Few children are capable of protecting themselves, nor should they have to; the problem is that they do have to rely on adults to protect them, and adults frequently fail.
>> What I REALLY would love to see as rape resistance strategies is how to recognize emotional abuse and manipulation that usually presage rapes <<
* How to recognize emotional abuse
* How to escape an abusive relationship
* How to help someone who is abused