Elizabeth Barrette (ysabetwordsmith) wrote,
Elizabeth Barrette
ysabetwordsmith

  • Mood:

Poem: "Some Kind of Help"

This poem came out of the January 7, 2014 Poetry Fishbowl.  It was inspired by a prompt from ellenmillion.  It also fills the "justice" square in my 8-12-13 card for the Genprompt Bingo fest.  It has been sponsored by janetmiles.


Some Kind of Help


People in trouble
want some kind of help, and
there are always those willing to give, but ...

Helping never helps
when it butts in from outside the situation
and ignores the circumstances at hand,
less about discovery
than colonization.

Helping never helps
when it's handed down from above
with command instead of compassion,
less about solving problems
than sweeping the annoyance out of sight.

Helping never helps
when it comes with demands for change
but no new resources to make that possible,
less about finding solutions
than shaming people.

Helping never helps
when it dispenses punishment
instead of justice and restoration,
less about righting wrongs
than making someone pay.

True help means
giving what the other person needs,
not just what you want to give.

Tags: activism, cyberfunded creativity, fishbowl, poem, poetry, reading, writing
Subscribe

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 7 comments
*nods* True help means *asking*, and honouring the wishes of the ask-ee. It's a very hard lesson to learn... but necessary for a good relationship.
Well said.

A problem is that many people don't want a good relationship; they're "helping" for self-gratification of some kind, and care fuckall about how the recipients feel.
Thank you for this.

We've been trying to teach this lesson to somebody who's proving very thick. :/ They think that their opinion of what would do other people better is objective, even after being told "no" many times and given reasons why forcing help is Not Okay. Still doesn't get it. O.o It seems to be he's trying to sell something under the guise of helping people.

- U.
Abusers are like that. If this person belongs to any professional organization, try checking its handbook of acceptable practices. "You can get fired" and "you can go to jail" may be useful things to add to the list of Not Okay reasons.
I would love to do that, but unfortunately he's out of reach there. The only place I can think of is a forum he's on, but he hasn't done anything explicitly against the rules there. Most of his attempts on this are made through a skype channel that is mostly filled with people who either agree with his views, he's given help to, or he's trying to wheedle into accepting his help.

- U.
Not much you can do to protect other people then; best just avoid him yourself. Some predators are very astute in finding positions where it difficult to penalize them.
*sigh* Very true. We've been sticking around for damage control, but it's not doing much. He'll hit a point where someone has to say something, and then brush right past it. About time to gtfo.

- U.