Elizabeth Barrette (ysabetwordsmith) wrote,
Elizabeth Barrette
ysabetwordsmith

  • Mood:

Internet Access as a Human Right

Here's an article about internet access as a human right.

I feel that human rights come in groups.  There are survival needs (food, water, health care, etc.).  There are sanity needs (freedom of expression, freedom of religion, freedom to marry, etc.).  And then there are the things that a society expects people to have in order to function as members of society, such as a residence or an education.  A society is obligated to provide people with the means to meet those expectations, because not doing so forcibly excludes people from society, which is dangerous as well as immoral.  Following the rules must always be an option for everyone, or else the system is unacceptably flawed for pushing people out of bounds and then blaming them for being out of bounds.  

Internet access is moving into that category.  It used to be an advantage if you had it, because most people didn't.  Now it's expected.  And it's rapidly getting to the point where you can't do anything without it -- there are bills that can only be paid online, classes that can only be paid online, job applications, on and one.  So.  If it's expected to be ubiquitous, then it has to be provided everywhere to everyone; and if not, then it's not okay to expect total saturation as if it were ubiquitous.  Even then, honestly, some people are just not compatible with cyberspace.  I don't really think it's okay to fling them out of society for that.
Tags: cyberspace theory, networking, reading
Subscribe

  • A Little Slice of Terramagne: YardMap

    Sadly the main program is dormant, but the YardMap concept is awesome, and many of its informative articles remain. YardMap was a citizen science…

  • Birdfeeding

    Today is sunny, muggy, and warm. I fed the birds. I've seen house finches and a squirrel. After lunch, we moved the rest of the walnut logs. Most…

  • Goldenrod Gall Contents

    Apparently all kinds of things go on inside goldenrod galls, beyond the caterpillars who make them. Fascinating. I've seen the galls but haven't…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 10 comments
Are libraries an adequate way of providing this access?

Like, I assume, pretty much everyone else who reads your LJ, I'm a huge fan of libraries, and believe that they are an excellent method of providing access to quite a few things in your third category, and probably some in your second category. (And, sadly, in many cities, they're de facto providing some things in the first category -- the library is a safe, climate-controlled place that homeless people can use for shelter during the day, but that's a different issue.)

They're a good source of education for some people, although, unfortunately, these days we're less interested in education than certification. Self-education doesn't count in our modern world, because the important thing is that you can DOCUMENT that you've taken a course, rather than that you actually have the knowledge and skills.

They're a source which can be used to provide the kinds of information that people need to be active, involved members of a democracy.

And they are a source of internet access, both through public terminals, and through free WiFi.
Last time I was at my local library (which was 2 or 3 years ago, admittedly), the only computer terminals they had were for searching their catalogue only.
You're German, right?

The ONE thing that the United States does better than ANY other country in the world is libraries. Our health care sucks (although, with luck, in five years we may be where the rest of the world was thirty years ago), our food and water safety is terrible, our criminal "justice" system rivals Stalinist Russia -- but our libraries are better than any other libraries on the planet.
At my local library, there are four or five computer stations specifically for searching the catalog, and about forty for internet access and general use, including a half-dozen or so set up for Spanish-speaking residents, next to the international book and magazine section.
Libraries are better than nothing. However, most libraries are chronically underfunded. Unless they get more funding (and space, and equipment, etc.) then it's not fair to heap a whole new universal providence on them.

>>Self-education doesn't count in our modern world, because the important thing is that you can DOCUMENT that you've taken a course, rather than that you actually have the knowledge and skills.<<

I am frankly waiting for society to tell the ivory towers to fuck the hell off with their life-destroying debt degrees. I'm in favor of education, but I think that being able to do the work is far more important than any degree. So I'm hoping that small businesses will hire people based on skills rather than paperwork, and make it possible again to get a job without having to hock your future on a gamble that maybe someone will hire you.
Libraries are better than nothing. However, most libraries are chronically underfunded. Unless they get more funding (and space, and equipment, etc.) then it's not fair to heap a whole new universal providence on them.

It's what they WANT to be doing, though. A great deal of the work being done in librarianship is in precisely this area. Librarians see this as EXACTLY what their job is.

More funding, sure. Funding libraries is a good thing. But one of the things that libraries want to be funded for is precisely to provide this service. They see their job as providing access to information, turning that information into knowledge, and ALSO as helping people to function as active members of their communities.

Helping to provide online access so that people can pay bills and do all the other minutiae of modern life that are more convenient online is as much a part of a library's job as providing space so that local groups can do political planning, or plan town gardens, or all those other things.

At least, according to the librarians I've talked to.
I am not certain that libraries have the capacity, with their limited budgets, to provide access for everyone... not without pushing out the actual *books*, magazines, newspapers, and all the other little things libraries do that are actually big things... There is something ineffable about simply *browsing the stacks* and seeing what pops out at you... since a well-organised library has things organised by topic and sub-topic, you can find things you wouldn't otherwise find relevant to what you're doing... they *still* don't have that working via computer even though it's been a research topic since I was a lad....
Librarians do see this as their job, though.

If we are arguing that access to information and to the ability to be active on the global community is a human right, then we, as a society, have a duty to fund that process.

Those funds should go to libraries for this purpose. Libraries are set up for it; librarians are all required to take coursework in it. This is their JOB. Why not use that fact?
Libraries are a good resource for looking up a few bits of information. They are not a good resource for the kind of everyday access that society increasingly expects. That's why universal internet coverage is important. Libraries can provide backup options for people who can't afford a computer. But many people don't have the time or transportation to do all their internet work at a library, and even with expansion the libraries couldn't really service everyone or even a sizable chunk of everyone.
Also: Making something universal has a profound effect. Universal suffrage had a profound effect on civil rights. Universal healthcare means a far better quality of life for everyone... (I have participated in this firsthand. It's pretty darn awesome.) The Internet is a *massive* force for change. I don't know .... yeah, I do. We Americans have had universal *telephone* service for decades. It's time to pull that into the 21st Century. If everyone has the web in their pocket... the implications could be staggering, with a reasonably high probability.

  • A Little Slice of Terramagne: YardMap

    Sadly the main program is dormant, but the YardMap concept is awesome, and many of its informative articles remain. YardMap was a citizen science…

  • Birdfeeding

    Today is sunny, muggy, and warm. I fed the birds. I've seen house finches and a squirrel. After lunch, we moved the rest of the walnut logs. Most…

  • Goldenrod Gall Contents

    Apparently all kinds of things go on inside goldenrod galls, beyond the caterpillars who make them. Fascinating. I've seen the galls but haven't…