Elizabeth Barrette (ysabetwordsmith) wrote,
Elizabeth Barrette
ysabetwordsmith

  • Mood:

Politics and Insanity

Sometimes people make me want to beat them over the head with a Logic textbook.  I mean, really ...

"Is Political Conservatism a Mild Form of Insanity?"

No, it is not.  Being conservative doesn't make you crazy.  We need conservatives in politics for the same reason a car needs brakes.  Their attention to tradition, and their instinct to look before they leap, are there to keep us from rushing blindly into stupid mistakes.

Being a liberal doesn't make you crazy either.  We need liberals for the same reason a car needs gas.  Their motivation and exploration allow us to go new places, because sometimes the old places aren't right for us anymore.

It is unfortunate and destructive that some radicals are masquerading as conservatives, while not adhering to actual conservative ideals; and that some are masquerading as liberals while not adhering to those ideals either.  They are crowding out some of the more sensible people, which is causing problems.  For instance, previously we talked about a Republican who lost an election because his constituents were allergic to facts and he refused to compromise his morals by pandering to them.  And there are still buffoons trying to oust Obama for not being born in America ... because they don't acknowledge Hawaii as part of America.  I am not at all happy with American politics right now.  A lot of the ideas  buzzing around are crazy.  The people?  Well, an alarming portion of Americans are suffering from depression, anxiety, or other mental problems so that probably laps over into the politicians.  But I'm disinclined to classify people as insane just because they belong to a particular political movement.

*headdesk*  I would be deliriously pleased if people could stop insulting each other for five minutes and actually talk about solving problems.
Tags: news, politics
Subscribe

  • A Little Slice of Terramagne: YardMap

    Sadly the main program is dormant, but the YardMap concept is awesome, and many of its informative articles remain. YardMap was a citizen science…

  • Winterfest in July Bingo Card 7-1-21

    Here is my card for the Winterfest in July Bingo fest. It runs from July 1-30. Celebrate all the holidays and traditions of winter! ( See all my…

  • Goldenrod Gall Contents

    Apparently all kinds of things go on inside goldenrod galls, beyond the caterpillars who make them. Fascinating. I've seen the galls but haven't…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 11 comments
THANK YOU. Yes. This.
I do what I can to encourage people to behave like responsible-for-things adults. It's hard when there are so few really good examples around and so much destructive and childish behavior. It makes me reluctant to support most groups or idealogies because I keep feeling like the moment I turn my back, they'll stick out their tongue at someone and I'll have to shut off the lights. I'd love to be able to do that to a roomful of politicians, in person. I've seen my mother do it in meetings when people got too snotty to hear, "Let's calm down and get back to business." It gets their attention.
IMO, certain flavors of what claims to be conservatism these days are insane, due not being based in reality. You can be reality-based and conservative. Certain flavors of liberalism aren't reality based either (idealized communism comes to mind).

When the ideology *requires* a disconnect from and denial of reality, or a "faith" in a "different reality" than the one we actually live in, then it becomes a pathology, or a cult. Until then, it's just politics.

That's where I draw the line: Are they handing me a glass of Flavor-Aid, and saying I must drink to 'belong'?
>> When the ideology *requires* a disconnect from and denial of reality, or a "faith" in a "different reality" than the one we actually live in, then it becomes a pathology, or a cult. <<

Okay, that's a valid argument. It may apply to some of the politicized subgroups, considering the problems that one Republican had with his former constituents, though I'm not sure it applies to the main parties yet.
The problem is, there haven't been many (if any) real conservatives in the GOP since Reagan.
Christy Todd Whitman? Ted Olsen? James Baker III?
People are methodically driving them away. And we NEED them. It's a serious problem.
Yes, I agree, and it's good to say this.

When I think of the great American conservatives, I think of Barry Goldwater in the mid-20th century, and Elihu Root at the very beginning of the 20th century. They both had strong, well developed, thoughtful philosophies of what it meant to be an American conservative. They also both distanced themselves from people who claimed to be conservative but were really reactionary radicals.

Also, thanks for noting that some people who claim the title Liberal are really more like radicals whose blatant distrust and suspicion undermines good government.

I've never registered as a Republican, but I have voted for some along the way. Some of those folks are pretty damn good, and do a good job of providing decent government service.
My closest match is the Green Party, but they rarely have candidates in my area. I usually vote for Democrats as closer to my preferences than Republicans, but sometimes I vote for a Republican if I like that candidate better. I prefer to check the candidates for important campaigns myself, rather than stick to party lines.

mdlbear

August 11 2010, 02:45:34 UTC 10 years ago Edited:  August 11 2010, 02:47:09 UTC

Well... the fact is that certain psychological problems are strongly correlated with self-identifying as "conservative". The key is self-identify -- the people who identify themselves as "conservative" these days have about as close a relationship to Barry Goldwater as a weasel does to a housecat -- they're not even the same species, metaphorically speaking.

Although the article attempts to claim that being "conservative" is itself a form of insanity, it's much more likely that causality runs the other way -- being crazy is likely to make a person identify with the other far-right nutcases out there.

In other words, it's not that being conservative makes you crazy, but that being crazy may make you "conservative".

Deleted comment

>>When I talk to conservative friends (I consider myself liberal generally), I often find that we have the same ultimate goals, just different approaches to those goals. And sometimes what appears to be an illogical stance is then explained to the point where I can see what's driving it and work better to find common ground. <<

That happens with me too. It's a key reason why I want to have some conservative friends. I need the counterpoint -- and I need to have some sensible people whose judgment I respect, for times when some conservative idea just seems incomprehensible to me and I need an explanation of it from their perspective. What's in the media is so exaggerated on both sides that it's often useless.

>>And sometimes what appears to be an illogical stance is then explained to the point where I can see what's driving it and work better to find common ground. <<

Precisely. If we can at least agree on a problem, we can try to find solutions that will be at least tolerable for all concerned. Sometimes the first few ideas to hit the table are stupid ones, and you really need to be able to talk through why they won't work for various people, until you can find something that will.

>>I'm not saying I don't meet those that frustrate me to no end--but it's usually because they have no desire to find common ground. I'm big on balance, which means including both approaches.<<

Dehumanizing the enemy and refusing to communicate are tactics that really frustrate me too. It bothers me to see them becoming more popular.

  • A Little Slice of Terramagne: YardMap

    Sadly the main program is dormant, but the YardMap concept is awesome, and many of its informative articles remain. YardMap was a citizen science…

  • Winterfest in July Bingo Card 7-1-21

    Here is my card for the Winterfest in July Bingo fest. It runs from July 1-30. Celebrate all the holidays and traditions of winter! ( See all my…

  • Goldenrod Gall Contents

    Apparently all kinds of things go on inside goldenrod galls, beyond the caterpillars who make them. Fascinating. I've seen the galls but haven't…